The Met's Ring Cycle: Götterdämmerung
by Angela Sutton
Photo: Ken Howard / Metropolitan Opera
Wagner's epic opera cycle hurtled to its fiery conclusion on Tuesday night at the Met, with the final installment, Götterdämmerung. Alberich's curse on the Ring of the Nibelungs finally sinks to its bitter end, pulling down the old order of the gods and closing the age of heroes.
The evening carried high drama, and Tuesday's cast delivered the heat. Jay Morris and Debra Voigt—the marquee singers for Siegfried and Brünnhilde, respectively—were absent, replaced by Stephen Gould and Katarina Dalayman. Gould gave an unforced and mellow Siegfried, and although he showed some signs of fatigue in the third act, he quickly recovered. Dalayman's performance was of a different order altogether: Brünnhilde carries much of the load in this opera, but Dalayman devoured the part, in total control of the action. I vastly preferred her to Voigt in this role.
Iain Paterson's Gunther demonstrated the character's slow descent into misery as he realizes just how far in over his head he is. Wendy Harmer's Gutrune served as a clear-voiced counterpoint to the swirling plots around her. The basses let it rip as well, with Hans-Peter König filling the hall with sound as Hagen, the plotter, playing against Eric Owens' more piercing Alberich in their gloomy second-act duet.
The cast got help from another great lighting scheme, consistently a strong point throughout the cycle. The Machine, in this case, mostly served as architecture in the scenes around the Gibichung's hall, though it also depicted the Rhine, Brünnhilde's rock, and the Norn's cave. This production (thankfully) didn't use it for distracting object-making, but rather to organize the stage space instead. The big miss here was the puppet-horse, Grane, which was toy-like and tragically inneffective as the mount for Brünnhilde's death ride.
The orchestra, under Maestro Fabio Luisi, nearly gave their best performance yet in the cycle. Götterdämmerung features a number of highly exposed horn and woodwind solos, all of which the players nailed. Yet, inexplicably, Siegfried's death music came apart at the seams; collectively, the orchestra managed to lay a flabby, disjointed egg. Maestro Luisi turned the funeral march portion into a quickstep, as if to put the pit out of its collective misery. This was particularly disappointing here, serving as the climax of some 16 hours of opera. Like true professionals, however, the pit regrouped almost immediately, at last sounding like wild Wagnerians during both Brünnhilde's immolation scene and the conclusion, as the Rhine's blue waters washed the wreckage away.
The second cycle of this controversial but ambitious production kicks off tonight (4/26) at 8:30 at the Met, for those who want to dive into the madness from standing room areas.